Stop Saying All Means All If You Don’t Mean It

November 04, 2025

We say “all means all” in education a lot. It’s on banners, mission statements, websites. We say it like a pledge, to ourselves, to our communities, to our students.

But let’s be honest: if your system isn’t specifically built to support the students who are furthest from opportunity, then “all” doesn’t mean all, it means average. And in Ferndale, average wasn’t good enough for the students who needed us most.

That’s why we decided to name it. Unapologetically.

The Data Made It Clear
Superintendent Camille Hibbler with students and staff.

When we developed our new Dynamic Plan, we committed to building it with community voice at the center and data at the table.

And the data didn’t whisper. It screamed.

It told us that our African American students were consistently underrepresented in advanced coursework, overrepresented in discipline referrals, and not making the same academic progress as their peers. Not because of their ability but because of our systems.

That wasn’t a surprise. It was a confirmation.

And it pushed us to stop saying “all” and start saying who.

We Didn’t Just Acknowledge the Gap. We Made It a Goal.

It wasn’t enough to name the disparity in a slide deck or a staff meeting. We had to build structures of accountability around it. So we wrote it into our goals.

In Ferndale, our Dynamic Plan includes public-facing Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) that explicitly track outcomes for African American students. From access to enrichment and AP courses, to academic achievement, to discipline rates - we’re tracking it, and acting on it.

This isn’t about singling out students, it’s about refusing to let them be overlooked. It’s about saying, “We see what’s happening, and we’re going to do something about it, consistently, publicly, and boldly.”

Is It Uncomfortable? Sometimes. But That’s Not a Reason to Stop.

I’ve heard the questions. Why call out one group? What about everyone else? Isn’t that divisive?

Superintendent Camille Hibbler at Ferndale Public Schools (Mich.).

No. What’s divisive is letting predictable disparities continue unchecked while claiming we’re working for all kids. What’s divisive is pretending equity is neutral work. It’s not.

This isn’t about placing blame. It’s about taking responsibility.

Because if we don’t lead with that kind of clarity, we end up relying on hope, and hope is not a strategy.

Equity Without Action Is Just Performance

We’ve all been in rooms where people say the right words “belonging,” “access,” “diversity”  but nothing changes.

The same gaps stay in place, year after year.

In Ferndale, we’re trying to move beyond the performance of equity and into the practice of it.

That means:

  • Setting clear, measurable goals

  • Naming the students who need the most urgent support

  • Following up with professional development, and resource shifts

  • Staying consistent even when the data gets hard to look at

We’re still building the muscle — but the mindset is already in place.

What I Know For Sure

I know we’re not going to close opportunity gaps by accident.

I know that avoiding race doesn’t protect relationships, it just protects inequity. And I know that every time we say “all” and don’t mean it, students notice. Families notice. Staff notice. And they lose trust. But when we’re bold enough to say exactly who needs what — and then back it up with resources, policy, and follow-through — that’s when belief starts to build.

That’s what we’re doing in Ferndale. We’re not there yet. But we’re not pretending either.

Because equity without honesty is empty. And “all means all” isn’t a slogan, it’s a commitment